West Virginia Mountaineers NFL Draft Preview
In last year's NFL Draft, there was only one Mountaineer drafted (Selvish Capers to Washington). This year, there could be up to seven drafted, including the likes of Robert Sands, Noel Devine, and Brandon Hogan. Here is our look at what teams are taking looks at your former Mountaineers, where they could go in the draft, and where we think they WILL go.
The Draft process began at the Draft Combine in Indianapolis, continued with WVU's Pro Day, and finished with individual workouts and interviews with NFL teams for the players. It's something akin to a three month job interview. We have shown you how the Mountaineers performed at the Combine and in WVU's Pro Day, so we'll dispense with breaking down stats, measurements, 40 times, etc.
We'll begin with perhaps the biggest names of this Mountaineer draft class in Noel Devine and Robert Sands. The two may have hurt their draft stock with the decisions they made about Morgantown. Last year, Devine elected to stay at WVU for his Senior season. His draft stock was higher following last season than it was at the close of this season. The injuries that plagued Devine's senior year, beginning with the LSU game, hurt his draft stock. Sands may have benefited from another year at WVU, but we'll never know. The player with possibly the most potential NFL talent from the Mountaineers could be oft-arrested, Brandon Hogan. His recent arrest could cause him to slide down the draft board. Take from it what you want, but ESPN's Mel Kiper said that he would pick Hogan over Sands. You'll find in the list below that St. Louis and Tampa Bay have spoken to, or worked out, multiple former Mountaineers. So don't be surprised if a few former teammates are also future teammates.
I'm going to list the Mountaineers that are most likely to be picked in this year's Draft, who they have spoken to, where they have worked out, and based upon what I have learned, will tell you where, when, and for whom will they be picked... if at all. (I will reveal my methodology for choosing a mock-Draft at the end)
- Noel Devine- Has visited or shown interest from the Falcons, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Tampa Bay, New Orleans, Baltimore, St. Louis, and Green Bay. Prediction: 5th Round #151- Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
- Robert Sands- Has visited or shown interest from St. Louis, Atlanta, and Minnesota. Prediction: 4th Round # 112- St. Louis Rams.
- Brandon Hogan- Has visited Carolina, Dallas, and NY Giants. Prediction: 5th Round Pick #143- Dallas Cowboys.
- Chris Neild- Has worked out for Kansas City and spoken to many teams that employ a 3-4 defense. Prediction: 6th Round Pick #193- New England Patriots
- Jock Sanders- Has worked out for or shown interest from St. Louis, Tampa Bay, and Kansas City. Prediction: 7th Round Pick # 223- Kansas City Chiefs
- J.T. Thomas- Has visited Miami and drawn considerable interest from Cleveland. Prediction: 7th Round Pick #247- Cleveland Browns.
- Scooter Berry- Has worked out for N.Y. Jets and Giants. Prediction: Undrafted but will have an opportunity to sign with the Jets as a FA.
Note: I used the same system for predicting draft picks as Mel Kiper and Todd McShay use, just in a different city. I went to downtown Charlotte to the bus terminal and gave $20 to the first homeless person I could find that knew how to read, showed him a few articles about the Draft, bought him a cup of coffee for $1.50 from the dispenser that uses the shot-glass sized coffee cups, and had him make my picks for me. I know it sounds far-fetched to think that Kiper and McShay utilize this system to create a mock-draft, but can you really prove that they don't?
11 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
i have a hard time...
believing that 6 WVU players will be drafted in this draft. we usually have a tough time getting 2 players drafted, much less 3 or more. i will go as far to say we will have 4 drafted. sands, hogan, devine, and jock. and i’m not too sure i believe jock will get drafted. fair or not, WVU has an enigma associated with them that we just don’t produce good NFL players (go ahead and start listing them, i’m sure i’m in for a shitstorm). other “big-time” colleges have great NFL prospects and players, whereas we have great college players that generally don’t pan out in the pros. even when teams like Texas or Oklahoma or Florida have bad years by their standards, they still produce 7 or 8 draft picks, with several in the first round.
i think one issue for our players is schemes. the spread offense generally doesn’t produce exceptional pro prospects (with some major exceptions saved for outstanding players who can shine in any system). pro scouts love QB’s and RB’s that come out of pro-style systems in college. The linemen in pro-style systems get a lot more credit as well, since in the spread, the ball is thrown quicker and they aren’t even asked to hold a block very long. WR is about the only offensive position that is well-respected by pro scouts in a spread system, and even with that, the numbers for WR are skewed by the system.
the 3-3-5 is not a system you see at the pro level either. there are years at WVU (including last year), that the defense works wonders. the problem for players trying to go pro is that in the 3-3-5, they have much different responsibilities than they would in a 4-3 or a 3-4 (which all pro teams run). scouts do not get to see our defenders actually play how they would on a pro team. the scouts would rather draft a mediocre guy that played in their style system (since they can see how he plays the actual position he’ll play in the pros) than draft a great player playing a position that doesn’t really exist on the next level.
to summarize, i’m not hating on WVU or on Mr. Wygal. i just have a really tough time believing that, given our past, we will have 6 guys drafted. we rarely have more than 2, and we even more rarely have an impact guy at the next level: slaton, white, henry, pac-man…all guys we expected to excel. our teams are always full of outstanding college football players. make no mistake. i am always proud to be a Mountaineer and they represent us well. i think pro scouts realize that they are great college football players because they fit into our schemes and are untested in pro-style schemes. this gets them drafted lower, and unfortunately most of the time, doesn’t make them good NFLers.
PS – i really hope they all get drafted and have very prosperous NFL careers. i wish them all the best and thank them for their years at WVU.
Put me down for Hogan, Sands and Neild to be drafted. Maybe Devine, but I doubt it. Don’t really care if we produce any NFL players as long as we win college football games.
producing NFL players helps us win College Footbal games
Devine Will be drafted
Players who should be in the Hall of Fame: Pat TIllman, Dwight White, Donnie Shell, L.C. Greenwood, Ray Guy, Steve Tasker, Jack Butler, Greg Llyod, Andy Russel, Cris Carter, Kevin Greene, Curtis Martin, Willie Roaf, Andre Reed and Jerry Kramer
"Baseball is like church. Many attend, but few understand." Wes Westrum
Canal Street Chronicles resident Steelers Fan
by WVPiratesfan on Apr 28, 2011 11:46 AM EDT up reply actions
We seriously posted this at exactly the same time.
Great minds…
www.smokingmusket.com
by Country Roads on Apr 28, 2011 11:47 AM EDT up reply actions
I was iffy on Jock and Thomas, but...
the homeless guy assured me someone would take a flyer on them in the 7th.
by Caleb Wygal on Apr 28, 2011 2:15 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Don’t worry. The only thing the homeless man told me that was correct was that Berry wouldn’t get drafted.
I feel bad for Noel.
He came in with a lot of hype but had some baggage and some question marks about his character, but he stayed for 4 years, got his degree, and from all we know did everything right off the field while he was here. He had a disappointing senior year (probably junior year too) for a multitude of reasons and then went undrafted. The kid deserves better, IMO, and while I understand that NFL teams aren’t going gaga over a 5’7, 160lbs RB with injury issues, the soft spot in me wants to see someone give him a chance because I feel like he has to have a niche somewhere where he can succeed.
www.smokingmusket.com
by Country Roads on May 2, 2011 7:43 AM EDT up reply actions
I’m working on a Draft recap that will show that going undrafted wasn’t necessarily a bad thing for Devine.
by Caleb Wygal on May 2, 2011 12:03 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I'm with you to a point.
I care about WVU winning over everything else too, but producing NFL players helps recruiting, which in turn helps win college football games. Clearly, as DDS pointed out, you can do some things with schemes, etc., to help maximize the talent you have. But it also helps to have NFL talent, especially on defense and on the offensive line.
www.smokingmusket.com
by Country Roads on Apr 28, 2011 11:46 AM EDT up reply actions
I'd like to point out
that the 3-4 defense is not completely different than the 3-3-5. Both utilize a nose tackle and inventive LB/secondary formations.
by TheMattROb on May 3, 2011 3:27 PM EDT reply actions

by 


















